top of page

From Te Pōrere to Palestine: a Conversation with Zarahn Southon

10 minutes ago
23 min read

Scott Hamilton


Zarahn Southon, Self-Portrait with Musket, 2005.
Zarahn Southon, Self-Portrait with Musket, 2005.

Zarahn Southon contains multitudes. He is a painter who spends long hours secluded in his studio, but he is also a political activist at home in the streets. He is committed to the history and culture of his Tūwharetoa iwi, but he paints in a style that is often associated with Europe, and he has studied at a French atelier. He is proud of his Jewish identity, but he has clashed with Zionist Jews, even inside his own family, over Israel's oppression of the Palestinians. He is an anarchist, but his anarchism owes more to the South Pacific history than it does to the ideas of northern hemisphere theorists. My interview with Zarahn was inevitably wide-ranging and fascinating.

 

Zarahn's detailed account of the events that preceded the famous 'last stand' of Te Kooti's army at Te Pōrere has the potential to change the way that many people think about the prophet and fighter. Only Zarahn could have told this story. His deep links to the whanau who fought at Te Pōrere and suffered at the hands of both Te Kooti and the Crown allow him to draw on oral tradition as well as written texts.


Zarahn's account of the interplay of European and indigenous approaches to art in the rohe of Tūwharetoa is equally interesting. He tells the story of the little-known school of arts set up there a century ago, and of the role of Pākehā as well as Māori in the adornment of local marae. His kōrero reminds us of the way that different peoples and cultures can complement each other as well as clash. As the great Tongan intellectual Futa Helu said, 'the ocean of humanity is fed by the rivers of many cultures'.



SH: Tongan New Zealand curator and art historian Kolokesa Mahina-Tuai has been a long-time critic of the distinction between 'art' and 'craft' and the way it has been used to keep work by Pasifika and Maori artists out of galleries. Why, she has asked, is the weaving, needlework, and carving of the South Pacific merely craft, while canvas painting, for example, is automatically accorded the status of art? And why should craft ever be a derogatory term, anyway? I think of your work as craft and art. It is made with intense care, using principles and techniques formulated slowly, over centuries, by guilds, but it is also unmistakably individual. How do you feel about the words 'craft' and 'art'?


ZS: I have no problem with the term 'craft', since historically both Māori societies and premodern Europe viewed art or craft as one and the same thing: an object produced through labor. The difference to modern European approaches is perhaps in Te Ao Māori; we still retain concepts regarding the intrinsic value of taonga.


In the last several hundred years, Western art has shifted from what Berger—building upon Benjamin—described as the religiosity of the crafted object to its commodification as private property. Although the effects of capitalism can be seen in contemporary Māori art, at the grassroots level, Māori still retain the metaphysical aspect of our taonga, i.e. they have mauri and intrinsic value and are a shared common good.


I think craft as a common good still exists across societies albeit fragmented within working class and peasant communities of differing cultural and ethnic backgrounds.


There is also a tendency in contemporary art theory and curatorship to divide Te Ao Māori and European art into two competing factions; the same happens in historical narratives. It's what Paul Monin argues is a binary of opposites that deny Māori agency. An example of Māori agency eager to form cross-cultural alliances can be seen in my rohe at Tokaanu in the 1920s and early 1930s.


In the 1930s in Tokaanu, my Ngāti Kurauia ancestors established an art school, Te Tūwharetoa Māori Arts and Crafts. They collaborated with the former director of the Wellington museum and member of the Board of Māori Arts James McDonald, who retired there in the 1920s. They hoped to revive and nurture traditional Māori crafts, and had a program for traditional European drawing and painting. Unfortunately, the project was short-lived due to McDonald being unable to secure adequate funding from the state; as a result, he died in poverty but was given an honorary burial by Ngāti Tūwharetoa.


McDonald helped with the building of our wharepuni Pūhaorangi in 1928. This Pākehā-Māori collaboration happened during the 1890s too. At Ōtukou Marae in the national park, former law enforcement soldiers helped build the wharepuni Ōkahukura. Oral tradition says some of the Pākehā men were escaped convicts and others armed constabulary defectors from the battle at Te Põrere in 1869. Two of the carved amo have gumboots.


My great grandmother Paekitawhiti’s uncle Koro Peeti commissioned James MacDonald to paint portraits of himself and elderly chiefs in the then academic colonial style. Charles Goldie and Lindauer had made earlier excursions through Taupō, completing commissions. The great respect afforded to Pākehā portrait painters is evident in the open letter by Horonuku Te Heuheu to all chiefs in the King Country, asking them to provide safe passage to Charles Goldie as he looked for Māori sitters.


My grandmother, a teenager at the Tokaanu native school during the 1930s, was greatly influenced by this cross-cultural collaboration. She herself, a landscape oil painter with an admiration for Rembrandt, was also a proficient weaver. My earliest memories of oil painting were the smell of her oil paints as worked on landscapes sat on her easel in her art studio on the farm in Kuratau.


I also find comfort in the fact that traditionally European oil painters of the Renaissance were seen as being no different from glass makers, health practitioners, or cheese makers. Pieter Kropotkin described the medieval guild systems as political brotherhoods and secret societies that fostered innovation, mutual aid, and creativity outside the suppression of the state. Being part of the free cities that dotted Europe at the time, workers were able to govern their own labour and were central to community life.


I don’t believe it was all that different within Māori society. Like journeymen of the European guilds, the practice still continues today, where specialists of carving or weaving travel the country teaching and creating their masterpieces. In the mid-20th century, once our wharepuni was built and the main carvings finished, it was left for the community to adorn with kōwhaiwhai and tukutuku weaving. My grandmother had fond memories of painting on the marae atea in the 1930s. Tokaanu's native school closed for the week for the Māori community to come together; it was a real community event. You still see this tradition today when new marae are built.


As a last note, when I was training with Ted Seth Jacob in France and San Francisco, he described his approach to painting as medieval. He taught painting using principles of light and the understanding of structure and form. He urged us to approach our craft with curiosity and spiritual seriousness. Ted had an attitude similar to that of the medieval craftsmen who painted the reverse side of paintings or sculpted the reverse of church gargoyles, knowing full well that the human eye will never see this labor; the reverse side was believed to be seen by the eye of God. I recall a Tūhoe master carver explaining to me that their teacher had a similar approach. Everything in the teacher’s house was carved, right down to cutlery and utensils. As an agnostic Māori, I find this appealing; it raises you to a different level of awareness and adds seriousness to your practice. My aim is to craft works of emotional intensity through intense physical labour for the common good within a socio-political and historical context.


SH: Mahina-Tuai is only one of a number of indigenous thinkers who have criticized the contemporary Western art industry for being excessively individualistic in its outlook. An artwork is treated as the product of a single human being, an isolated creative. Yet you point out that, both in the South Pacific and in pre-modern Europe, artmaking was often a communal activity. You have been very interested in the role of guilds in preserving and extending art traditions...


ZS: I noticed the excessive individualism in art school; we were all competing for access to limited resources. To the credit of lecturers, they wanted us to live as practicing artists and attempted to teach us skills to navigate an increasingly hostile capitalist system. This was in the 1990s after the neoliberal assault on higher education by Ruth Richardson.


The pedagogical approach at the art school in the 1990s emphasised postmodernism, entrepreneurialism, and identity politics. In my view the neoliberal assault on higher education, the fall of the Berlin Wall, and the Soviet Bloc resulted in a deep cynicism among Gen X. We are seeing the shocking results today with the rise of fascism. My art then focused on the rise of fascism; I could see similarities between what happened in the Weimar system and what was happening then and more obviously now.


In my view, in the 1990s didn't see any genuine left-wing alternative in the academy with class consciousness to provide the necessary pushback to neoliberalism. Working-class theory, apart from perhaps a nod to anarchism, was actively suppressed and discouraged. I think the research by Catherine Liu and Gabriel Rockhill unpacks a lot of the anti-communist and anti-socialist pedagogy of the last forty years within cultural institutions and the academy. Unfortunately, the turn away from class politics has had disastrous effects.


As far as art practice goes, this may seem trivial, but I noticed the difference between studying in traditional ateliers in Europe with their group cohesion compared to the individualism that I was taught in art school in the 1990s. It’s reflected not just in pedagogy but also, for example, in the setup of a traditional life drawing studio.


The Atelier life drawing studio is set up in a semi-circle with the model centered; there are Rembrandt sketches showing this setup in the seventeenth century. I believe the ritual of group formation around one person, with the north or south light and a teacher devoting their time to students improving skills based upon classical principles, helps form group cohesion. The Soviets understood this, hence their academy and Soviet realism. It was very different from the university art school experience with its more informal life drawing setups where everyone is out for themselves. I see it when I teach: I set the class up for social cohesion in a semi-circle, like synchronicity of form in kapa haka, and then when new students arrive, they break away from the group and start moving things around, and the cohesive dynamic is lost.


Allie Eagle was my first life drawing teacher, and she understood all this very well. She was instrumental during the 1980s and 1990s in changing life drawing practices across Auckland. Having been part of the original 1960s-70s art revolution—breaking with the drudgery and the misogyny within colonial art academia—she was able to renew life drawing practices with political vigour, placing the model front and center. Acknowledging the lack of skilled figurative life painting teachers in Aotearoa, she was the teacher that encouraged me to pursue further study abroad.


SH: You are known for your politics as well as your art. You have written extensively about the situation of indigenous peoples, like your own iwi Ngāti Tūwharetoa, and you have documented protest movements—the land occupation at Ihumatao, for example—with words and images. You've also written, on a more theoretical level, about anarchism, a political current that you find attractive. How did you become interested in anarchism? How does your art relate to your politics?


ZS: Like most, I had a very narrow window to anarchism growing up during the '80s with punk and metal trends. It wasn’t until art school that I started to take socialism seriously, studying artists of Weimar Germany and reading political theory. When reading art history, especially in the 20th century, you realise so many artists were either communists, socialists, or anarchists. Picasso was the most famous communist and anti-war activist. The revolutionary socialism of 19th and 20th century art is actively suppressed by curators worldwide and then subverted to please liberal tastes.


After I completed my studies in 1998, I lived briefly in Sevilla. It was in Andalucia that I was introduced to the rich anarchist history of Spain. Realising anarchism was a serious form of political organisation, I endeavored to learn as much as I could about it.


It wasn’t until I met my partner—her father is a linguist and friend of Noam Chomsky—that I began taking anarchist history and theory more seriously. Early on I was influenced by Chomsky, Kropotkin, and Bookchin. Bookchin relied on the Athenian democracy of the agora and believed that, despite its flaws, it was proof that humans could organise without centralized power. I noticed the parallels to anarchism in Māori history and lore. From our creation stories to our tikanga marae. Bookchin praised the Greek agora and polis; however, we have our own agora—the marae ātea, the public setting for debate, where most decisions for the collective are argued by orators, deliberated by the collective, and arrived at through mutual consensus.


Mutual aid is basically our whakawhanaungatanga and manaakitanga. It is far from perfect; we have hierarchy, and I believe traditionally those hierarchies weren’t as entrenched as they are now. I believe hierarchy within the Māori community has become more entrenched with colonialism and its class systems, but the fragments of a Māori form of anarchism are still there.


To be honest, I’m not one of those 'dyed-in-the-wool, capital A anarchists' either. I am as interested in and intrigued by Marxist theory, global south communism, anti-colonial struggles, and Soviet history as I am in anarchism. Our history of the Pacific Panthers and Ngā Tamatoa proves that indigenous resistance weaves together many strands of anti-colonial, anti-imperialist, and anti-capitalist theory. And also Māori aren't as sectarian as Western leftists. I think it's to do with our hapū systems of tikanga (correct ways of being), whakapapa, and whanaungatanga (relationships), and as you know, we always respect another tribe’s way of being, their tikanga. Our whakapapa always leads back to whakawhanaungatanga. What may be right for them may not be right for us and vice versa, but we still respect the lore. This is autonomy; this is how we have tino rangatiratanga. It's very different from the purity tests of Western leftism.


When we look at socialist struggles, anti-colonial rebellions, and national liberation projects, we see that  indigenous peoples of the world have been at the forefront of fighting against the evils of Western imperialism for five hundred years. Marx and Engels recognised this. We may be at an end point to Western imperialism, as the viciousness of Western liberal democracy has been laid bare in Palestine.


As a Māori familiar with my own iwi's history resisting colonialism, I understand now that many white anarchists living in the imperial core have no understanding or are completely ignorant of indigenous anti-colonial struggle and history. This became evident post October 7th, 2023, when some anarchists living in the imperial core denounced the actions of prisoners breaking from a concentration camp. They willfully push Western propaganda and hegemony onto the poorest and most vulnerable people on the planet.


Hence the reason—while the West actively carries out a genocide and threatens the global south, threatens to annihilate Iran, has its military building up globally to defeat China, and turns increasingly towards fascism —I do not agree with the “All Imperialisms” narrative. Such a stance only serves one interest, and that is the dominance of Western imperialism on the global south and, by extension, indigenous peoples of the world. Finkelstein put it to an interviewer: 'Despite the political purges by Stalin during the 1930s, you wouldn’t denounce the USSR during Operation Barbarossa.'



SH: You have Jewish heritage, and count the great anthropologist Roger Keesing as one of your relatives. Keesing's studies of the Malaitan people the Kwaio, who have defied both colonialism and Christianity, are classics that are still used in anthropology programmes, and yet they haven't found a wide readership in the South Pacific. We've discussed Lightning Meets the West Wind, Keesing's powerful account of the Malaitan uprising against tax collectors in the 1920s and the genocidal campaign of revenge that followed it. Has Keesing's work influenced your art and your writing?


ZS: Despite growing up proud of our Jewish heritage with my grandparents organising a large Asher and Keesing reunion during the '80s, I never encountered Roger Keesing’s writing until I began reading David Graeber and Marshall Sahlins. Roger Keesing’s father Felix Keesing, an anthropologist too, worked with Pitt Rivers, Peter Buck, and Apirana Ngata. The whanau connection to Felix Keesing is through my great grandfather Jack Atirau Asher. My great-grandfather's father was David Asher, and his mother was a puhi from Ngā i Pūkenga, Katerena Te Atirau. David Asher’s grandfather was Hartog Keesing. Hartog built the first synagogue in Auckland and was an acquaintance of the dreadful governor Grey.


When reading their histories, you get the sense that all of these Māori leaders, while they were negotiating with the Crown, were both interlocutors and teachers to university professors and anthropologists like Felix and historian Ormond Wilson. It's really fascinating history, even if they—both Māori and Pākehā—came at it with a colonial lens at times. And it was the young Roger Keesing that sort of turned all of this on its head, being influenced by Marxism and the radicalism of the 1960s.


Lightning Meets the West Wind is one of my favorite books, and after I read it, I presented Roger Keesing’s work at a whanau reunion at Te Whetu o te Rangi marae in Welcome Bay. His work on the Malaitan uprising was very relevant because Ngāti Pūkenga, like the Kwaio, were a mercenary tribe.


Zarahn Southon, Te Porere, 2005.
Zarahn Southon, Te Porere, 2005.

SH: After I wrote an essay about your art and showed it to you, you zeroed in on my discussion of Te Kooti, saying that I hadn't captured the complex way that your tūpuna related to the prophet. I remember you quoting a whānau member who was talking about the battle of Te Pōrere. 'We built the pa, but he lost it', your relative said. Te Kooti is a figure who has fascinated not only Māori but also Pākehā writers—Maurice Shadbolt and Errol Braithwaite wrote novels about him, and Kendrick Smithyman produced poem after poem about him. I remember another Pākehā poet saying that Te Kooti was the most remarkable person in the history of these islands, that he was an Aotearoan Che Guevara and a local Moses combined. But has there been a tendency to romanticise Te Kooti amongst left-wing Pākehā, myself included? Are we in danger of forgetting his darker side? You emphasized that your ancestors had little choice but to work with Te Kooti when he turned up in their rohe, and that he did not always behave well while he lived and fought in the area.


ZS: There has been a tendency to romanticise Te Kooti, and to reduce history into a 'binary of opposites' in my opinion leads to a lack of the tactical and strategic thinking necessary for understanding the present. I find the Che Guevara comparison shallow—while they shared exemplary capabilities in guerrilla warfare and anti-colonial resistance, it should be obvious to anyone interested in anti-colonialism that their political ideology couldn’t be more different. I agree with Dun Mihaka when he criticized Te Kooti and Rongomaiwhiti as offering nothing new and liberatory for Māori, quite possibly an attitude shared by many Māori of that time when you consider that Māori were far outnumbered by constabulary at Te Kooti's final battle at Te Pōrere in 1869.


At Tokaanu marae growing up, we were all fascinated by Te Kooti; my grandmother was an admirer. However, our kaumatua of Ngāti Kurauia recounted that our tūpuna, despite being considered 'rebel Māori' by the crown and despite their respect for Te Kooti, were against his push into our rohe and his plan to settle at Papakai in the national park. Our tūpuna were Paurini Karamu (Ngāti Kurauia, Ngāti Turangitukua, Ngāti Waewae) and Katarina Paurini nee Pikiao (Ngāti Kurauia, Ngāti Te Aho) with her uncle Hare Tauteka, along with other rangatira of Ngāti Kurauia and Ngāti Aho.


I was told by a respected kaumatua—whose mother, like my grandmother, grew up during the 1930s and 1950s with people alive at the time of the final battle at Te Pōrere—that the thirty members of Ngāti Tūwharetoa that lay in the Te Pōrere urupā were kidnapped by Te Kooti as slaves to build his redoubt. They were executed after the battle by members of the Te Arawa flying column. An interesting fact is the dividing wall in the redoubt that Judith Binney describes in her book Redemption Songs was occupied by members of Tūwharetoa on one side and the other side by Ringatū during the battle.


These oral traditions are documented in the Te Kahui Maunga: The National Park District Inquiry Report from 2013, in Redemption Songs, and in other historical documents.


Also, questions remain around the design flaws of the redoubt said to have been constructed by kidnapped people, possibly Ngāti Tūwharetoa. Te Kooti named the redoubt Ziklag after the fateful biblical story. Binney recounts that, when he saw the redoubt, Te Kooti knew he was doomed. Make up what you will about the day of the battle. Te Kooti was drunk after being provided a bottle of whiskey along with new guns by Irish gun runners.


Previously, in December 1868, when news came of Te Kooti and an armed force of three hundred Ringatū advancing toward Taupō, a meeting of Ngāti Tūwharetoa rangatira was convened at Ōruanui. The 40-member committee of rangatira consisted of Paurini Karamu along with leaders from Tokaanu. Katarina’s Pikiao uncle is Hāre Tauteka, and her cousin is Te Herekiekie Kingi. After the meeting my tūpuna decided to ask the government to supply them with soldiers under their command, guns, powder, and tinder to defend themselves from Te Kooti with. Their request was denied by the Crown.


An invitation was published in Te Waka Maori o Ahuriri, along with the whakataukī:


‘E tupu e te kumara, e ohu e te anuhe’


This whakataukī explains that while the kumara (that is, Ngāti Tūwharetoa) develops, caterpillars (Te Kooti and his followers) gather around to consume them.


In August 1869, Paurini Karamu, Horonuku Te Heuheu, and Matuaahu Te Wharerangi of Otukou again met Te Kooti on his arrival to Taupō. Paurini Karamu, however, chose not to remain with Te Kooti and departed at Tuhua to his whanaunga of Ngāti Waewae at Whanganui in the hope of raising a war party to fight Te Kooti. At Tokaanu an attack was imminent, and due to a lack of ammunition to protect themselves, an attempt was made to melt the church bell down for musket shots.


A mass exodus occurred at Tokaanu before Te Kooti’s followers attacked in September of 1869. Katarina Pikiao escaped with her uncle Hāre Tauteka and his nephew Kīngi Herekiekie, withdrawing to Tūrangarere, which was Ngāti Rangi land to the south of Murimotu. They awaited there for Paurini Karamu to bring reinforcements from Ngāti Waewae. Only those sympathetic to Te Kooti and the Hauhau remained at Tokaanu. Homes at Tokaanu were looted and torched by Te Kooti’s followers, and weeks later crops were destroyed by constabulary and Māori auxiliaries under the command of Captain Saint George and Henare Tomoana.


Hare Tauteka sent four scouts to Tokaanu, but they were caught by Te Kooti’s followers. They were killed, their bodies dismembered and ritually displayed in a swamp. This ritualistic killing proved to be partly the reason Rewi Maniapoto abandoned Te Kooti since one of the scouts was Rewi’s relation with strong ties to Waikato. On learning of the deaths, it was recorded at the time by Captain Gilbert Mair that my tupuna, Hare Tauteka, was deeply grieved and devastated at the news. I believe in an act of muru: Hare Tauteka commandeered soldiers alongside Renata Kawepo opposing Te Kooti at Te Pōrere on October 4th, 1869.


Returning to my previous comment on the members of Tūwharetoa that are buried at Te Pōrere. A plaque placed there by the New Zealand Historical Trust in the 1960s is inscribed with the words 'Here lie thirty followers of Te Kooti'. For years many kaumatua in the area complained that statement was a lie, saying they weren't followers, that many of the Tuwharetoa ancestors who lay there had in fact been kidnapped by Te Kooti.


As I stated earlier, Te Kooti is rightly seen as an anti-colonial resistance fighter, but his misogyny, dominance of innocent Māori through kidnapping and murder, and his sexual behaviour deserve scrutiny. The practice of kidnapping Māori for his fighting force was recorded by Binney in Redemption Songs. It was a fact that husbands joining his fighting force had to give their wives; refusal would be met with execution, and the men’s bodies would be dismembered and ritually displayed. Tell me any genuine revolutionary that would accept that. And to argue that these initiation processes were or are part of Te Ao Māori is just plain racism. It's the reason you’ll find many Māori like my elders were and still are hostile to glorifying Te Kooti. Perhaps the brutality he meted out to settlers and 'friendly Māori' can be compared to Nat Turner’s Rebellion, but the murder of children, the abduction of innocent Māori, and the sexual abuses need strong criticism.


SH: I don't always agree with you, but I admire the fearlessness of your thinking. You haven't been afraid to write against the flow of opinion on the right or left. You were one of the very few people on the left to oppose the new firearms laws that were rushed through parliament after the Christchurch massacre. Can you explain why you took that unpopular stance?


ZS: That my opinion would be considered against the grain in the face of rising fascism demonstrates just how far the debate on workers' rights to defend ourselves has shifted in the last fifty to one hundred years. We've gone from working-class militancy last seen in 1951 to wishy-washy liberalism. We should consider there was a time when it wasn’t controversial for a leftist like Orwell to opine, 'That rifle, hanging on the wall of the working-class flat or labourer's cottage, is the symbol of democracy. It is our job to see that it stays there.'


I also question the framing of who gets to hold the power of violence, and in this case it isn’t the working class but capital and state power. Neither does the law address the underlying systemic racism that creates the conditions that led to the Christchurch terrorist attack. It's not working-class politics but rather liberal posturing.


The liberal approach to history and non-violence downplays the brutal struggles fought by the working class and indigenous peoples globally that gave us rights we take for granted today. The historian James Belich confirmed it was Māori armed resistance that pushed Britain and the New Zealand government to make concessions. It was largely due to the fact the British Empire needed 25% of its total imperial global army concentrated on the NZ campaign to suppress Māori resistance and genocide of Māori. The Māori army had fewer at its peak than 4,000 to 5,000 fighters compared to 18,000 British and colonial troops. Arming ourselves—albeit reluctantly—against British imperialism halted our complete annihilation.


I think a lot can be learned by looking at contemporary socialist approaches to arms by leftist organisations worldwide. The YPG in Rojava, Zapatistas in Chiapas, and other EZLN groups across Latin America.


Currently in the USA, leftist working-class organisations are The Brown Berets, Socialist Rifle Association, Sylvia Rivera Gun Club, Yellow Peril Tactical, and Huey. The Newton Gun Club, the Pink Pistols, and Black Girls Shoot have formed community self-defense groups. These groups are dedicated to community self-defense in an obviously resurgent white supremacist society.


What many of these leftist groups have improved upon in the last decades is addressing and changing the traditional machismo and hierarchy that plagued traditional armed leftist organisations during the '60s and 70s.


Allie Eagle photographed with Briar March, who released the documentary Allie Eagle and Me in 2004.
Allie Eagle photographed with Briar March, who released the documentary Allie Eagle and Me in 2004.

SH: One of the aims of Reef Shark is to try to shine some light on writers and artists of the past who have been unjustly neglected. There are so many magnificent out-of-print books from our region and so many fine artists whose work is relegated to the storage rooms of galleries. Who are the Aotearoan and Oceanian artists that you think haven't had the attention they deserve?


ZS: There needs to be more attention placed on artists who are active within their communities. Te Maari Gardiner (Ngāti Tūwharetoa, Te Arawa, Ngāti Raukawa) is an artist that comes to mind; she is an illustrator and graphic designer, but as in all things Māori, her talents don’t stop there. Te Maari has been a community organiser for the last several decades in the Taupō region. She was an organiser for a large Ngāti Tuwharetoa exhibition in the 1990s, and I remember Richard Nuns and Hiri Melbourne performing at the powhiri at Hirangi marae. It was a magical moment and a source of Tuwharetoa pride.


Te Maari is also an archivist and historian of Ngāti Tūwharetoa, in particular in the Tongariro Park rohe of Ngāti Hikairo, and she wrote the book about Okahukura marae. She carries on a rich tradition of Tūwharetoa historians and archivists, the most famous being John Te Herekiekie Grace. I have fond childhood memories of his niece Snowey Hikairo Grace. She was a passionate teacher and curator who managed the small whanau-run Tokaanu museum in the 1970s and 1980s. When I see Te Maari, I am reminded of these amazing aunties.


Te Maari Gardiner created the stunning stained glass windows in the Anglican church at Tokaanu. With its kōwhaiwhai and tukutuku, it is a significant church because it is the site in memory of the killing through utu by our tūpuna of the Anglican minister Te Manihera and Kereopa in 1847.


I think there also needs to be a large retrospective in a large art institution of the life and work of the painter Allie Eagle. She was a real trailblazer as a militant of the lesbian separatists of Aotearoa and also an excellent teacher and community activist. What’s fascinating is the many contradictions both in her work and lifestyle, like, for example, her turning to Christianity late in life. I think in the future her life and work will be a treasure trove for historians. There also needs to be particular attention paid to the work she and other members of collectives were doing in the '70s and '80s for community organising and committee facilitation.


SH: You've written a lot about the tragedy of Palestine and have been involved in protests here in solidarity with Palestinians. There's been a determined effort by figures like Brian Tamaki and Sheree Trotter to enlist Māori on the side of Israel in the conflict; Tamaki has infamously staged haka to disrupt pro-Palestine marches. How much support does Israel have within Te Ao Māori? And how split has Aotearoa's Jewish community been by Israel's war in Gaza?


ZS: There is very little support for Israel within the Māori community. The vast majority of Māori support Palestine and see in Palestinian resistance the resistance of our ancestors. Tamaki and the Indigenous Coalition for Israel and the present Māori cohort in government, are outliers and a minority. The shameful part is their grandkids will live with the burden that their tūpuna supported a genocide.


My own opinion is I don’t believe that centering the Jewish community in the time of genocide being enacted by Western powers through the racist colonial state helps Palestinians. That said, Sh'ma Koleinu—Alternative Jewish Voices, by Marilyn Garson, Māori Jewish activist Sam Kingi, and groups like Dayenu: New Zealand Jews Against Occupation show that the tradition of the Jewish left opposing crimes of capitalism and imperialism is alive and well. They do this by actively coordinating and in most cases taking their lead from Palestinians.


SH: There are a lot of dispiriting things happening in the world of the 2020s. Are there places and developments, though, that give you hope? Where should we be looking if we want to catch a glimpse of a better world?


ZS: I don’t think we can be dispirited, nor does hoping for anything help either. Throughout history humans have resisted and overcome great odds, but for various reasons, for too long, Western leftism of the elite intellectual class has been captured by defeatism and cynicism. This while the global south does socialism their own way. There are positive developments everywhere, particularly in the global south and western Asia, with China playing a central role in economic development.


Over the years I’ve been closely following protests in France, like the Mouvement des Gilets Jaunes (Movement of the Yellow Vests) riots in 2018 and the latest youth riots. What is striking is the youth uprisings happening within the imperial core are outwardly leftist and working-class, opposing austerity and imperialism. Most of the youth come from the black and Arab communities of the banlieues and organised during the Black Lives Matters protests in 2020. In the present protests we are seeing intergenerational working-class organising, with the children of parents active during the Mouvement des Gilets Jaunes organising and taking to the streets across France.


I believe if there is anywhere to turn back the tide of fascism growing in Europe and across the G7, it is within these European working class movements, including anti-military conscription protests in Germany and anti-austerity protests in Belgium, housing rights in Spain, and dock strikes in Italy; which are beginning to influence protests in surrounding countries.


The ruptures that led to working-class victories of the 20th century happened over the course of the 19th century with many failures—in France think of the failed uprisings of 1830, 1848, and 1872. Despite the failures, the theories and organisational practices of the working class had ripple effects across societies and borders.


It is no coincidence that Free Palestine plays a key part in these uprisings. Despite the last three years of gaslighting and the coordinated Hasbara spin, a genocide perpetuated with the help of the billionaire class tech bros has been livestreamed to the working class masses and the masses have had enough. The working class are taking to the streets in record numbers.


Where these protests will lead is an open question, and there is plenty to critique about the lack of wider organisational structures, yet the uprisings are happening more frequently, and that is historically seen as a catalyst to greater change. With the global financial system at breaking point, US imperialist wars of aggression, and NATO leader Mark Rutte foolishly talking of leading the world toward WW3, it stands to reason that people will rise up.


The future is a blank canvas, and nuclear armageddon is the closest it's been ever. Revolution can either take time or come with speed and ferocity—even exiled Lenin, Kropotkin, and Goldman witnessed the Tsarist collapse in 1917 in astonishment. World War One was capitalism's answer to crisis, and it falls upon us to decide whether we will send our children into World War Three. Having had the experience of photographing the large numbers that have turned out for free Palestine and other protests over the last decade and having witnessed the current situation of working class youth in Europe, I know there are large sections of the working class that clearly say 'no!'


Opinion polls across the West show how unpopular the war on Iran is, with two-thirds of Americans disapproving. Also polls consistently show an upward trend of disapproval of Israel's military campaigns. In the United States there also has been a shift in public perceptions of socialism, with 58% of youth aged 18-34 years old viewing socialism positively and 43% overall. These are significant shifts in public perceptions especially within the imperial core.


Fifty years of anti-socialist propaganda is clearly failing in the face of the material conditions faced by the working class of the world.


In Aotearoa, Toitū Tiriti and the pro-Palestine movement have galvanised a generation of new activists. With every rightward turn, the people organised and the hīkoi was the largest in a generation. This is people power.


I will finish with a quote attributed to Jean Paul Sartre: "You don't fight fascism because you're going to win. You fight fascism because it is fascist." When reading this I am reminded of our whakatauāki that gives us strength:

Kaua e Mate Wheke, Me Mate Ururoa,' which translates to 'Do not die like an octopus; die like a hammerhead shark.'


Tongariro te maunga

Taupo te moana.

Tūwharetoa maranga rā,

Tūwharetoa maranga rā.


Mount Tongariro is our sacred peak.

and Lake Taupo, our waterway

Tūwharetoa people arise.

Tūwharetoa people arise.


(These lines come from the Ngāti Tūwharetoa anthem, 'Kua Tai Mae Nei'. The song was composed by Wairemana Tamaira and first recorded by Carl Karepa in 1966.)


_


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page